Problems with make
The concept of make is clearly a good idea, and this idea proliferated to produce many versions of make. C and C++ compiler vendors typically included their own variation of make along with their compilerthese variations often took liberties with what people considered to be the standard makefile rules, so the resulting makefiles wouldnt run with each other. The problem was finally solved (as has often been the case) by a make that was, and still is, superior to all the other makes, and is also free, so theres no resistance to using it: GNU make. This tool has a significantly better feature set than the other versions of make and is available on all platforms.
In the previous two editions of Thinking in Java, I used makefiles to build all the code in the books source-code tree. I automatically generated these makefilesone in each directory, and a master makefile in the root directory that would call the restusing a tool that I originally wrote in C++ (in about 2 weeks) for Thinking in C++, and later rewrote in Python (in about half a day) called MakeBuilder.py. It worked for both Windows and Linux/Unix, but I had to write extra code to make this happen, and I never tried it on the Macintosh. Therein lies the first problem with make: You can get it to work on multiple platforms, but its not inherently cross-platform. So for a language thats supposed to be write once, run anywhere (that is, Java), you can spend a lot of effort getting the same behavior in the build system if you use make.
The rest of the problems with make can probably be summarized by saying that it is like a lot of tools developed for Unix; the person creating the tool couldnt resist the temptation to create their own language syntax, and as a result, Unix is filled with tools that are all remarkably different, and equally incomprehensible. That is to say, the make syntax is quite difficult to understand in its entiretyIve been learning it for yearsand has lots of annoying things like its insistence on tabs instead of spaces.
All that said, note that I still find GNU make indispensable for many of the projects I create.